HomeFree ToolsBuild vs Hire Calculator
Interactive Calculator
Build vs Hire: Which Costs Less Over Three Years?
Model agency build costs, in-house salary overhead and hourly freelance burn side by side — then see the break-even point and break-even timeline for your project.
3-Year TCO
Agency vs in-house vs hourly.
Region Presets
US, UK, EU, India salaries.
Break-even
See the crossover point.
Board-Ready
Export a summary.
Three-Year Cost Inputs
Adjust the inputs to match your situation. Results update live.
Three-Year Total Cost of Ownership
The assumptions this model makes
| Model | Formula | Three-year total |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed-scope agency | $15,000 build + hosting & maintenance at 15% of the build cost per year, for 3 years | $21,750 |
| In-house team | ($150,000 senior × 0.5 + $110,000 mid × 0.5) × 2 engineers × 1.30 benefits & overhead, for 3 years, plus $15,000 one-off recruitment | $1,029,000 |
| Hourly freelance | $75 per hour × 600 estimated project hours × 3 years | $135,000 |
Defaults shown: United States region preset, 2 in-house engineers, a $15,000 agency build delivered in 3 months. Every input above is editable and the table follows it.
Cheapest option
Fixed-scope agency
$21,750 over 3 years
Total savings
$1,007,250
vs In-house team
First release
3 months
agency vs 12+ for in-house
Illustrative three-year TCO, not a quote. Replace inputs with your actual numbers for a board-ready comparison.
When to build, hire or go hourly
The cheapest option depends on whether software is a project or a permanent capability. Here is how to think about each model.
Fixed-scope agency
You have a defined project with clear deliverables and a deadline.
A fixed-scope agency prices the work per milestone, delivers working software you can review weekly, and lets you stop after any release. You avoid recruitment, benefits, equipment and idle time. The vendor carries the delivery risk, so a mis-estimate is their cost, not yours.
Best for:
First products, defined features, platform rebuilds, migrations.
In-house team
Software is your permanent core product with a long roadmap.
An in-house team gives you institutional knowledge, full-time availability and direct control over priorities. But salary is just the beginning — benefits, equipment, recruitment fees, management overhead and idle time between projects add 30–50% on top. A two-engineer US team costs $120,000+ per year before a single line of code is written.
Best for:
Ongoing product development, core IP, 24/7 operational systems.
Hourly freelance
You need flexible capacity and have strong technical leadership in-house.
Hourly billing gives you flexibility — scale up for a sprint, scale down when things quieten. But cost grows with every hour, scope creep has no ceiling, and you carry the risk of a weak hire. Screen, manage and QA the work yourself, or pay someone else to.
Best for:
Small tasks, overflow capacity, specialised one-off work.
What goes into the three-year TCO
Most comparisons only look at salary or the build invoice. A fair three-year total cost of ownership includes everything — costs that are easy to miss until they appear on the P&L.
| Cost component | What it includes |
|---|---|
| Agency build | Milestone price + hosting/maintenance at ~15% of build cost per year. No salaries, no recruitment, no idle time. |
| In-house salary | Base salary × headcount × 3 years. US senior engineers average $130k–$180k; mid-level $90k–$130k. |
| Benefits & overhead | Health insurance, payroll tax, equipment, office space, software licences — typically 25–40% of base salary. |
| Recruitment | Agency fees, job board listings, interview time and signing bonuses — $10k–$25k per hire in the US. |
| Management | Engineering manager time, 1:1s, code reviews, planning — often overlooked but real cost. |
| Hourly burn | Rate × hours worked. Scope creep means hours grow; there is no ceiling on a time-and-materials contract. |
The calculator includes all of these. Replace the defaults with your actual numbers for a board-ready comparison.
Common questions
How does this build vs hire calculator work?
It compares three engagement models over a three-year horizon: a fixed-scope agency build (milestone pricing plus hosting), an in-house team (salaries, benefits, recruitment and overhead) and hourly freelance billing (rate × estimated hours). Each model's three-year total cost of ownership is calculated, then the break-even point — the month at which the cheaper model has saved more than the upfront difference — is shown alongside a timeline.
Why is a fixed-scope agency usually cheaper than hiring in-house?
For a defined project, an agency delivers a finished outcome at a known price, while an in-house team costs 12+ months of salary before the first release. A two-engineer in-house team in the US costs $120,000+ per year in salary alone, before benefits, equipment, recruitment and idle time. An agency pod delivers the same first release for $5,000–$25,000 — and you can stop after any working release.
When should we hire in-house instead of using an agency?
When software is your permanent core product and you need a long-term roadmap team. Many clients start with a fixed-scope build, then hire internally once the product and requirements are proven. The calculator helps you see the crossover point: if you need the same capability for 24+ months, in-house often wins on total cost.
Are the salary and benefit presets accurate for my region?
The presets are directional planning ranges seeded from commonly published salary data for the selected region. They exclude equity, bonuses and company-specific perks. Replace them with your actual numbers as soon as you have them — the calculator accepts custom inputs for every field.
Why show ranges instead of exact numbers?
Because a single-point three-year forecast from a budget input would be false precision. Project scope drifts, hiring timelines slip and hourly billing has no ceiling. We therefore project a base case and show a ±30% planning band, so you plan for a downside, a base and an upside rather than a number that will not survive contact with reality.
Can AnyPlace help us make this decision for our specific project?
Yes. Send us your calculator output through the contact form and we will respond with a scoped recommendation: whether a fixed-scope build, an in-house hire or a hybrid approach makes sense for your timeline, budget and long-term roadmap.
Content last reviewed October 2026.
Related services
Where This Decision Lands
If the answer is we still need the work done, these are the service pages that state scope, price and fit.
- Custom Software DevelopmentScope doc + tested releasesDiscovery typically 1–3 weeks; first usable release in weekly sprints after that
- Dedicated Developers & Team ExtensionWorking code in your repo weeklyDeveloper embedded within 1–2 weeks of agreement; monthly commitment
- IT Consulting & Technology AdvisoryAudit report + technical roadmapAdvisory review typically 1–3 weeks, depending on system complexity
Pairs with
The other tools that answer the same question
These run in your browser, need no signup, and send nothing to us.
Software Project Cost & Scope Estimator
Calculate preliminary milestone budgets, delivery timelines, and sprint scopes for custom web, mobile, and AI software.
Open the toolMarketing Budget & ROAS Calculator
Model channel spend, visits, leads, customers, CAC and ROAS from a monthly budget before committing a dollar.
Open the toolAI Search Visibility Checker
Audit a page's structured data, headings and answer structure for AI citation readiness — and get a prioritised fix list.
Open the toolTELL US ABOUT YOUR PROJECT
Tell Us What to Build, Fix or Modernize
Send a short brief. We reply within 12 hours with clarifying questions and a discovery quote — no retainers, no spam.
What Happens Next
Request a Discovery Quote
Share your goals and timeline. NDA signed first if needed.
12-hour response